$5.29 Cereal Chiller
Vanilla Milkshake with Fruity Pebbles
- Calories
- 821
Sheetz menu
Sheetz Milkshakes & Smoothies Menu
Updated 27 August 2026 43 Items
$4.49 Starting at
765 Average calories
43 With calorie counts
The shake board is the most calorie dense section at Sheetz by a distance. 43 builds sit here, priced from Create A Shake Chocolate at $4.49 to $9.99, and the average lands at 765 calories. That average is higher than the burger section.
Cheezecake shakes are the signature range. Classic Cheezecake is $5.19 and 911 calories, and the flavoured builds run to Peanut Butter Brownie Cheezecake at $5.39 and 1,687 calories. Below them, the Create A Shake line starts at $4.49 and lets you pick the flavour.
Smoothies are the counterweight and they are genuinely lighter. Strawberry Banana publishes 202 calories, against 1,989 for Caramel Fudge Brownie Blast at the top of the shake range. That is a difference of nearly two thousand calories inside one section, which is the reason this page prints both numbers.
Nothing on this page matches those filters. .
Found elsewhere on the menu
Every item
All Sheetz Milkshakes & Smoothies items (43)
Filter by price or calories, or sort the grid to put the cheapest builds first.
$5.29 
$5.19 Classic Cheezecake
Cheesecake Milkshake with Graham Crumbs
- Calories
- 911
$4.49+ Create A Shake Chocolate
Made with Ghiradelli
- Calories
- 589 - 953
- Sizes
- 2
$6.99 Dazzling Dragon Smoothie
Pink Dragon Fruit, Mango, Banana, Apple & Wild Blueberry
- Calories
- 528
Under 350 cal $6.99 Dazzling Dragon Smoothie
Pink Dragon Fruit, Mango, Banana, Apple & Wild Blueberry
- Calories
- 269
$5.39 Decadent Delight Cheezecake
Make Your Own Chocolate, White Chocolate, Dulce, Peanut Butter or Brownie
- Calories
- 971
$5.39 Fruit Fuzion Cheezecake
Make Your Own and Add Fruit Flavor
- Calories
- 976
Under 350 cal $6.99 Pineapple Aloha Smoothie (apple juice)
Pineapple, Mango & Papaya
- Calories
- 239
$6.99 Pineapple Aloha Smoothie (yogurt)
Pineapple, Mango & Papaya
- Calories
- 498
$5.39 Premium Cheezecake
Make Your Own with Cookies & Cream, Brownies, or Reese's PB Cups
- Calories
- 1,092
$6.49 Reese's Caramel Cup
Made With Reese's
- Calories
- 1,150
$5.39 Sh'morez Cheezecake
Cheesecake Milkshake with Chocolate, Toasted Marshmallow and Graham Crumbs
- Calories
- 959
$4.99 Sh'morez Milkshake
Chocolate, Toasted Marshmallow and Graham Crumbs
- Calories
- 1,205
Under 350 cal $6.99 Sh'trawberry Fantasy Smoothie (apple juice)
Strawberry & Banana
- Calories
- 259
$6.99 Sh'trawberry Fantasy Smoothie (yogurt)
Strawberry & Banana
- Calories
- 518
$9.99 Acai Strawberry
- Calories
- 537
$9.99 Blue Coconut Pineapple
- Calories
- 577
$5.39 Candy Cane Cheezecake Milkshake
- Calories
- 938
$5.39 Caramel Brownie Cheezecake
- Calories
- 1,530
$5.29 Caramel Fudge Brownie Blast
- Calories
- 1,989
$5.29 Chai Me Pumpkin Milkshake
- Calories
- 844
$5.39 Cinnamon Roll Cheezecake Milkshake
- Calories
- 969
$5.29 Cinnamon Roll Milkshake
- Calories
- 707
$4.49+ Create A Shake Banana
- Calories
- 367 - 1,164
- Sizes
- 2
$4.49+ Create A Shake Black Raspberry
- Calories
- 803 - 918
- Sizes
- 2
$4.49 Create A Shake Blue Raspberry
- Calories
- 617
$4.49 Create A Shake Cherry Vanilla
- Calories
- 745
$5.19+ Create A Shake Cookiez-n-Cream
- Calories
- 367 - 1,588
- Sizes
- 2
$4.49+ Create A Shake Peanut Butter
- Calories
- 367 - 1,738
- Sizes
- 2
$4.49+ Create A Shake Strawberry
- Calories
- 539 - 830
- Sizes
- 2
$4.49+ Create A Shake Vanilla
- Calories
- 510 - 763
- Sizes
- 2
Under 350 cal $4.69+ Make Your Own Smoothie
- Calories
- 210 - 378
- Sizes
- 2
$9.99 Passionfruit Dragon Fruit
- Calories
- 461
$4.69+ Peanut Butter & Jelly
- Calories
- 454 - 532
- Sizes
- 2
$5.39 Peanut Butter Brownie Cheezecake
- Calories
- 1,687
$5.29 Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie
- Calories
- 1,729
$5.19+ Peanut Butter Lover
- Calories
- 979 - 2,463
- Sizes
- 2
$5.29 Peppermint Bark Milkshake
- Calories
- 797
$5.39 Pumpkin Cheezecake Milkshake
- Calories
- 1,094
$5.29 Pumpkin Pie Milkshake
- Calories
- 866
Under 350 cal $4.69+ Strawberry Banana
- Calories
- 202 - 369
- Sizes
- 2
$4.69+ Strawberry Lemonade
- Calories
- 735 - 1,251
- Sizes
- 2
Under 350 cal $4.69+ Strawberry Pina Colada
- Calories
- 296 - 503
- Sizes
- 2
Prices come from the Sheetz ordering system for a Pennsylvania reference store and vary by location. Calorie counts are the values Sheetz publishes for the base build. Updated 27 August 2026. Found something wrong? Tell us.
Price list
Sheetz Milkshakes & Smoothies prices and calories
Every size that carries its own price gets its own row, sorted cheapest first.
| Item | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Banana Milkshake Regular | $4.49 | 874 cal |
| Black Raspberry Milkshake Regular | $4.49 | 803 cal |
| Chocolate Milkshake Regular Made with Ghiradelli | $4.49 | 778 cal |
| Create A Shake Blue Raspberry | $4.49 | 617 cal |
| Create A Shake Cherry Vanilla | $4.49 | 745 cal |
| Peanut Butter Milkshake Regular | $4.49 | 1,363 cal |
| Strawberry Milkshake Regular | $4.49 | 728 cal |
| Vanilla Milkshake Regular | $4.49 | 699 cal |
| MTO Smoothie Regular | $4.69 | 294 cal |
| Peanut Butter & Jelly Regular | $4.69 | 454 cal |
| Strawberry Banana Smoothie Regular | $4.69 | 285 cal |
| Strawberry Colada Regular | $4.69 | 399 cal |
| Strawberry Lemonade Smoothie Regular | $4.69 | 993 cal |
| Sh'morez Milkshake Chocolate, Toasted Marshmallow and Graham Crumbs | $4.99 | 1,205 cal |
| Classic Cheezecake Cheesecake Milkshake with Graham Crumbs | $5.19 | 911 cal |
| Cookiez-n-Cream Milkshake Regular | $5.19 | 1,263 cal |
| Peanut Butter Lover Milkshake Regular | $5.19 | 1,521 cal |
| Caramel Fudge Brownie Blast | $5.29 | 1,989 cal |
| Cereal Chiller Vanilla Milkshake with Fruity Pebbles | $5.29 | 821 cal |
| Chai Me Pumpkin Milkshake | $5.29 | 844 cal |
| Cinnamon Roll Milkshake | $5.29 | 707 cal |
| Peanut Butter & Jelly Large | $5.29 | 532 cal |
| Peanut Butter Fudge Brownie | $5.29 | 1,729 cal |
| Peppermint Bark Milkshake | $5.29 | 797 cal |
| Pumpkin Pie Milkshake | $5.29 | 866 cal |
| Candy Cane Cheezecake Milkshake | $5.39 | 938 cal |
| Caramel Brownie Cheezecake | $5.39 | 1,530 cal |
| Cinnamon Roll Cheezecake Milkshake | $5.39 | 969 cal |
| Decadent Delight Cheezecake Make Your Own Chocolate, White Chocolate, Dulce, Peanut Butter or Brownie | $5.39 | 971 cal |
| Fruit Fuzion Cheezecake Make Your Own and Add Fruit Flavor | $5.39 | 976 cal |
| Peanut Butter Brownie Cheezecake | $5.39 | 1,687 cal |
| Premium Cheezecake Make Your Own with Cookies & Cream, Brownies, or Reese's PB Cups | $5.39 | 1,092 cal |
| Pumpkin Cheezecake Milkshake | $5.39 | 1,094 cal |
| Sh'morez Cheezecake Cheesecake Milkshake with Chocolate, Toasted Marshmallow and Graham Crumbs | $5.39 | 959 cal |
| Banana Milkshake Large | $5.49 | 1,164 cal |
| Black Raspberry Milkshake Large | $5.49 | 918 cal |
| Chocolate Milkshake Large Made with Ghiradelli | $5.49 | 953 cal |
| Peanut Butter Milkshake Large | $5.49 | 1,738 cal |
| Strawberry Milkshake Large | $5.49 | 830 cal |
| Vanilla Milkshake Large | $5.49 | 763 cal |
| MTO Smoothie Large | $5.59 | 378 cal |
| Strawberry Banana Smoothie Large | $5.59 | 369 cal |
| Strawberry Colada Large | $5.59 | 503 cal |
| Strawberry Lemonade Smoothie Large | $5.59 | 1,251 cal |
| Cookiez-n-Cream Milkshake Large | $6.19 | 1,588 cal |
| Peanut Butter Lover Milkshake Large | $6.19 | 2,463 cal |
| Reese's Caramel Cup Made With Reese's | $6.49 | 1,150 cal |
| Dazzling Dragon Smoothie Pink Dragon Fruit, Mango, Banana, Apple & Wild Blueberry | $6.99 | 528 cal |
| Pineapple Aloha Smoothie (apple juice) Pineapple, Mango & Papaya | $6.99 | 239 cal |
| Pineapple Aloha Smoothie (yogurt) Pineapple, Mango & Papaya | $6.99 | 498 cal |
| Sh'trawberry Fantasy Smoothie (apple juice) Strawberry & Banana | $6.99 | 259 cal |
| Sh'trawberry Fantasy Smoothie (yogurt) Strawberry & Banana | $6.99 | 518 cal |
| Acai Strawberry | $9.99 | 537 cal |
| Blue Coconut Pineapple | $9.99 | 577 cal |
| Passionfruit Dragon Fruit | $9.99 | 461 cal |
Prices from the Sheetz ordering system for a Pennsylvania reference store, updated 27 August 2026.
The shake is the meal
A $5.29 shake at 1,989 calories carries more than most full meals on the sub board. Ordered alongside a burger and Fryz it pushes a single stop past two thousand calories, and almost nobody counts a drink that way when they order it.
Sizing helps more than flavour choice does. The Create A Shake line at $4.49 sits several hundred calories below the Cheezecake range for a similar price, and the fruit smoothies drop lower again. If a shake is the point of the stop, the calculator will show you what the rest of the order has room for.
Keep browsing
Other Sheetz menus
Answers
Sheetz Milkshakes & Smoothies questions
How much is a milkshake at Sheetz?
Create A Shake builds start at $4.49. The Cheezecake range runs from $5.19 to $6.49 depending on the flavour.
What is a Cheezecake shake at Sheetz?
It is a milkshake blended with cheesecake, which is the Sheetz signature shake format. Classic Cheezecake is $5.19 and 911 calories, and flavoured versions sit above it on both price and calories.
How many calories are in a Sheetz milkshake?
Between 367 and 1,989 depending on the build, with a section average of 765. The Create A Shake line is consistently lighter than the Cheezecake range.
Does Sheetz have smoothies?
Yes, and they are the lightest thing on this board. Strawberry Banana publishes 202 calories, and the whole fruit smoothie range sits well below the shakes.
Can you customise a Sheetz milkshake?
Yes. The Create A Shake line exists for exactly that, and the touchscreen offers the flavour, the mix ins and the size. Each addition changes the published calorie figure, which the calculator will account for.
What is the highest calorie item at Sheetz?
Among single serve drinks, Caramel Fudge Brownie Blast at 1,989 calories is at the top of this section. Only the group sized food platters go higher, and those are built for sharing.
Are Sheetz shakes available 24 hours?
Yes, at stores where the MTO kitchen runs overnight, which is almost all of them. Seasonal flavours rotate through faster than the standing range, so pumpkin and peppermint builds come and go.